BC Institute Against Family Violence Newsletter
Dedicated to the Elimination of Family Violence Through Research and Information
small fontslarge fonts 

The Undervalued Foster Parent

The roots of foster care are lost in antiquity. In the so-called category of "custom adoption" there remains a tradition within some aboriginal populations of an informal blur between the status of fostering and adoption. In their extended families, a child may be raised by an aunt, uncle or grandparent, on a temporary or permanent basis. It has not been unusual for breast feeding to be provided by one of these relatives.

However, for society in general, there is an absolute legal distinction between fostering and adoption.

Foster homes are classified under Ministry of Social Services guidelines, mainly according to the formal qualifications and experience of the foster parents. Payment for their services are graded accordingly. Acknowledging the 24-hour periods of responsibility, foster parents' hourly rates could be calculated sometimes as only a fraction of the minimum wage. This is unfortunate given the important responsibilities of fostering, as described in the following concepts of care requirements:

Foster care in general

Unspecialized foster care for children will extend over periods of weeks, months or years, either until the natural parents are able to resume custody, or until adoption is arranged, or in some instances for an indefinite period of time. A special function in the case of infants is to avoid any unnecessary delay in inaugurating and maintaining a caregiver-infant attachment process.

Receiving home

A receiving home is prepared to accommodate a child of any age on an emergency basis during deliberations for assessment and planning in accordance with perceived ongoing needs. The managing foster parent must adapt to the admission of a new foster child at any hour of the day or night, with little or no information about special needs. The role of a receiving home is to provide basic food, shelter and clothing on a short-term basis.

The home's logistics may require a system of coding to identify formula bottles in the refrigerator in accordance with a particular infant and a supply of clothing of many sizes to be kept in readiness. Usually, the stay in a receiving home is quite short in terms of days. Thus, the administrative turnover of admissions, discharges, and individual arrangements for visits present daunting challenges. Many "natural" parents would be unable to meet the social and protective needs.

Special needs fostering

In a special needs foster home, care is given to children who may require careful administration of medications, home administered physiotherapy (as for cystic fibrosis), application of dressings, special measures to cope with a hearing defect, or other requirements that may be met if the affected child were to be brought up within her/his own family.

Therapeutic foster parents

Finally, the most demanding fostering requirements are presented by infants and children born after prenatal exposure to a mother's addicting drugs, such as heroin, methadone, codeine, cocaine, or diazepam (Valium). They are said to have Neonatal Abstinence Syndrome (NAS), recently referred to as Infants of Substance Using Mothers (ISUMs).

Some of these infants appear to cope with ordinary care, or they may show withdrawal symptoms within a few days after birth or after weaning deprives them of a mother's drug that was present in the breast milk. Most of the severe NAS effects in infancy require special management in hospital, in rooms protected from the stimulation of ordinary light and noise. Discharge from hospital is promoted at the earliest possible time to allow a beginning of infant-caregiver attachment (bonding).

Some of these infants require special care that most parents are unable to provide during early infancy. They are visited weekly at home or in a foster home by a supportive and educating community health nurse. Hopefully there are periodic medical and developmental assessments.

These infants require such extraordinary skills and tolerance, that foster parents with the required proficiency for these demands have come to be termed Therapeutic Foster Parents (TFPs). Rather than an NAS infant being transferred because of their exasperating needs and provocations, these special TFPs pride themselves on their determination to retain them without transfer.

Initially in 1988, in conducting the monthly reviews at Sunny Hill Hospital, the Medical Director1 of the NAS program noted that some foster mothers were more successful than others, and that on occasion his decision to transfer a non-thriving infant to another foster home resulted in immediate improvement in weight gain, acceptance of feeding, and reversal of symptoms of regression, such as tremors.

After examining some details that characterized the more successful foster parents, the hospital's imaginative social worker2 collaborated with an equally creative resource person3 in the Ministry of Social Services to inaugurate a special selection system for the Ministry to establish this elite category of TFPs.

They accepted requests from foster parents previously screened by the Ministry, and conducted a more stringent selection protocol - hence the birth of the informal category of Therapeutic Foster Parents.

The hospital social worker's successor4 collaborated with the Ministry's resource worker to establish a series of monthly meetings of the TFPs to exchange views and experiences, and to hear lectures by authorities on such subjects as attachment, separation, or comforting a very agitated child.

As some NAS infants emerge into childhood, there may be a new set of complications that require special handling, and possibly timely intervention to limit the chance of a serious handicap extending or worsening into adolescence and adulthood. These medical problems appear similar to those found among some children who had been exposed prenatally to mother's alcohol habit (so-called Fetal Alcohol Syndrome). The need for special management and attempted nurturing can be met, if at all, by the same elite group of foster parents.

Challenges presented by some affected children

With individual variations, some of the infants and children who require therapeutic foster parent care may present a combination of any of the following challenges to their caregiver:

Frequent agitation, explosive outbursts, irritability and whininess, shrill and implacable screaming which provokes exasperation in the caregiver, embarrassment caused by continuously screaming in a mall or other public place (with an inability to respond to soothing), episodic destruction of household objects, injurious aggressiveness toward a caregiver or other children, self-destructiveness (hair pulling, finger biting, injurious head banging), and fearless self-endangering activities.

In addition, the child may suffer from night terrors and habitually insist on sleeping with one caregiver, thereby forcing the caregiver's partner to seek a peaceful night's sleep in another room. The child may exhibit impulsive behaviour, show unreasonable fear of a new situation, or be easily frustrated.

Compulsive behaviours the child may exhibit include insistence on a spoon or bottle to be always in precisely the same place, refusing food even to the point of impending malnutrition, tremors and/or rejecting food when confronted by low stimulation, (such as ordinary household sounds or a bright sky, a lighted television screen or a skylight). In some cases, the child may suffer with hyperactivity and a short attention span.

Special capabilities of therapeutic foster parents

Therapeutic foster parents must have special proficiency in dealing with the challenges presented by some children with special needs. Their care giving strengths include, with individual differences:

Uppermost, therapeutic foster parents are dedicated to providing empathetic and sensitive nurturing, including opportunities for promoting a caregiver-infant attachment process. They are required to maintain a 24-hour-a-day responsibility with only occasional respite of a few hours, must have the ability to comfort or provide calm for an agitated child, and sensitivity and wisdom to select between affectionate cuddling and/or isolation in dealing with unacceptable behaviour.

Therapeutic foster parents exhibit a readiness to provide companionship and feeding when a foster child must be hospitalized (even with other foster children being cared for in the foster home). They have self-control to resist when provoked to spank, an interest and ability to teach "natural" parents who may be jealously hostile or to counsel prospective adopting parents. They recognize subtle gains and reinforce a child's new achievements, as well as having an early perception of a new problem requiring therapeutic intervention. They are effective in using their own family supports to assist in providing foster care.

In addition, they may require the ability and dedication to administer prescribed exercises and medications reliably, to cope with city traffic while transporting an unruly child to clinic, be careful to maintain safe conditions in the home and surroundings, and have a proficiency in humoring a child who misbehaves compulsively. They may need resourcefulness and skills in assuring dietary intake in the face of feeding refusal or habitual regurgitation that threatens malnutrition, a proficiency to maintain a daily log of all parental visits and visits to clinics, and ability to record significant developmental events in a style useful to doctors, infant development professionals and social workers. They may feel a need to invest in a larger home and vehicle for fostering activities. Some therapeutic foster parents also exhibit a readiness to adopt and provide nurturing of a foster child whose compulsive needs cannot be met by anyone else.

Unjustified notoriety

In some instances unjustified notoriety is attached to some foster parents who have become so exhausted by a child's extraordinary provocations that they are unable to care for the child anymore; with the child becoming so unbearable as to require serial transfers to a succession of foster homes. The transfers themselves worsen the child's ability to socialize, and unjust criticism is placed on the foster parents.

A major, unsung activity of foster parents is their dedication to developing a thorough familiarity with the details of growth and development of their foster children, and to be reasonably competent to provide nurturing and access to the child's needs for attachment to her/his long term caregiver.

Unfortunately, in the wake of the recent enlightened concept about the credibility of child witnesses, foster parents who provide a home for older children may be scapegoated by a disturbed foster child, with false and mischievous accusations of sexual abuse in the foster home, whereupon it becomes mandatory for Ministry officials to immediately remove the child or the alleged molester. Fostering cannot be resumed until an arduous investigation establishes the falsity of the accusation, if indeed such an outcome can be achieved.

Infants engaged in a delicate attachment process in the same home will be removed at the same time. A particular threat to these foster parents is the prospect of losing their own blood-related children as well, if the accusation is not disproved beyond a doubt.

Sydney Segal, M.D.

1 This author
2 Kathryn Arkko, B.S.W.
3 Norma Carey, M.S.W.
4 Patricia Reid, B.S.W.